Contents
The main theme for A Jury of Her Peers is Gender Roles; much of the tension in the story results from what the women understand and what the men are blind to.
Susan Glaspell’s “A Jury of Her Peers” illustrates how women may be swayed by patriarchal views if they are trusted by men, but that women’s confinement to the home sphere creates a shared female experience that ultimately wins out because men cannot understand it. This thesis was very basic.
The main conflict surrounds the death of Minnie Wright’s husband and the fate of Minnie Wright. There is a conflict over how men view women vs how women would want to be viewed and treated.
Simply put, thematic conflict is an implied battle of ideas. While pursuing their respective goals, characters (protagonist vs antagonist) can represent opposing philosophies and incompatible worldviews concerning the story’s main theme. As characters clash, so do their philosophies.
Although John Wright’s act of strangling the songbird was a single cruel act, it symbolizes the way he has treated Minnie throughout their marriage. … The act of killing the bird also “killed” Minnie’s remaining hope, causing her to retaliate in response to years, rather than one single act, of mistreatment.
In a sense, the canary symbolizes Mrs. Wright (the former Minnie Foster). She is a woman married to an abusive man who has sucked all the joy out of life for her. … Wright most likely killed the canary by wringing its neck.
Throughout the story, Glaspell uses the symbols of the dead canary, the kitchen and the quilt to not only promote gender inequality roles but show what life must’ve been like for Minnie; imprisoned by her husband. The dead canary and its cage was a pivotal piece of evidence that the women discovered.
The chair symbolizes the absent Minnie Wright. The rocking chair “was dingy, with wooden rungs up the back, and the middle rung was gone, and the chair sagged to one side”(Glaspell 157), which was not anything like Mrs. Hale used to remember it being. Mrs.
How does Mrs Hale feel about leaving her kitchen in the beginning of the story? She looks around her kitchen, scandalized that she has to leave it in the state that it is: her bread is ready for mixing and only half the flour is sifted.
For a proper and balanced Thematic Argument, a story must present its theme and anti-theme in equal amount. A story about telling the truth must be filled with characters who lie. A story about justice must contain plenty of injustice. A story about freedom must show what it is like to have freedoms taken away.
Theme is the writer’s message about life, whereas plot describes the main events and sequence of a story. A key difference is that themes are often short and can be said in one sentence, whereas the plot of a story can be lengthy.
For Mikage, the kitchen is a symbol of warmth, comfort, and security.
How does the symbol of the birdcage reinforce a feminist theme? –It shows that women were not allowed out of the house. -It illustrates the ultimate control that women had over things that mattered to them. -It suggests that women could break out of the roles that they were supposed to fill.
The names of the characters from the story “A Jury of Her Peers” are significant, lending added meaning to Glaspell’s narrative. It is interesting, too, that all three of the female characters have names derived from the Hebrew language; that is, they are traditional names. The name Martha means “bitterness” in Hebrew.
The quilt represents her mental instability. Since she was always home alone she spent most her time making quilts. In the play Mrs. Hale points out that the one she was just working on was so nice and even then the pattern went all over the place.
In Trifles, the birdcage symbolizes the prison of Mrs. Wright’s marriage. Glaspell draws connections between the bird Mrs. Wright kept and, which it…
Minnie had bought the canary to keep her company because she was so lonely on the farm. When she married her husband, John, she was a pretty young girl who liked to socialize. … The canary was the only thing she had to help her feel better about being isolated from the world.
In “A Jury of Her Peers,” the irony is that the men laugh at the women for focusing on what they consider insignificant trifles, but it is in these details that the evidence behind and reasons for Mr. Wright’s death can be found.
Hale and Mrs. Peters should have shown the evidence of Minnie Wright’s crime to the county attorney George Henderson, who’s investigating the killing of Mr. Wright. The women know that Minnie is guilty of the crime and that the dead bird would provide evidence of a powerful motive.
The women find justification in Mrs. Wright’s actions and go about hiding what they find from the men. In the end, their obstruction of evidence will seemingly prevent a conviction. The story ends here, and does not move into the occurrences after they leave the house.
The one key element that helped them to see the truth was that John had killed Minnie’s poor little bird. That must have been the end of it for her. She snapped and she killed him. He took the one thing that she enjoyed (music–and she used to sing in the choir, too) and destroyed it.
It serves as a double understanding in that the men who enter the house to explore the crime scene are already biased and against Minnie because the house was untidy. To add to this, having a quilt sewn badly is significant in that women often quilt to relax, and to feel serene in the comfort of their own home.
In Glaspell’s “A Jury of Her Peers”, the main protagonist is Martha Hale, the wife of Lewis Hale.
“A Jury of Her Peers” and “Trifles” share the same plot; however, “Trifles” is a play and “A Jury of Her Peers” is a short story. … However, the short story gave more content towards the story Glaspell was telling her readers by showing the point of view of both the men and women, while “Trifles” just explains the story.
In “Jury”, why does Mrs. Hale find it difficult to cross over Mrs. Wright’s threshold? She has never visited before, although she feels she really should have.
The main themes in Trifles are gender, isolation, and justice. Gender: the male characters only want to gather evidence of Minnie’s crime, whereas the women come to understand the emotional pain that drove Minnie to murder her husband.
Minnie Wright’s concern over the canning jars of fruit symbolizes her parallel concerns about her gender role in society as a wife and housekeeper. … The broken jars are linked to the brokenness of Minnie’s situation.
The setting of this story is in a rural American community, Dickson County, at the turn of the twentieth century. This setting is extremely important to establishing the plot and themes of the story.
In literature, theme refers to the main idea or moral of the story. Sometimes this main idea or moral is stated directly, and sometimes the reader has to think about the main idea. … For example, the tale of the tortoise and the hare typically ends with, “Slow and steady wins the race.”
Examples. Some common themes in literature are “love,” “war,” “revenge,” “betrayal,” “patriotism,” “grace,” “isolation,” “motherhood,” “forgiveness,” “wartime loss,” “treachery,” “rich versus poor,” “appearance versus reality,” and “help from other-worldly powers.”
The theme of a story is what the author is trying to convey — in other words, the central idea of the story. … The theme of a story is woven all the way through the story, and the characters’ actions, interactions, and motivations all reflect the story’s theme. But don’t confuse theme with the story’s plot or moral.
the idea the writer wishes to convey about the subject—the writer’s view of the world or a revelation about human nature. To identify the theme, be sure that you’ve first identified the story’s plot, the way the story uses characterization, and the primary conflict in the story.